Fantasy Fights

Intelligent, unique MMA analysis

Random Thoughts on UFC 194

With Conor McGregor and Luke Rockhold’s victories at UFC 194, my week of wrongness has hopefully come to a merciful end. Hats off to both McGregor and Rockhold for terrific performances.

I have to express extreme disappointment with the McGregor-Aldo match. I’m not disappointed that McGregor won; I actually think it’s a great thing for the featherweight division. I’m just disappointed that the fight was so short. I love nothing more than a great back-and-forth fight and thought we would get it with McGregor vs. Aldo. Unfortunately, it was not to be. All of the build-up, the international press tour, the trash talking, the promos… all for a 13 second fight.

I do wonder if McGregor’s trash talk and taunting caused Aldo to fight more emotionally than he normally would. It seemed like Aldo came out more aggressive than usual, wanting to really hurt McGregor… but that’s already a lot of speculation for such a short fight. Still, seeing Aldo lunging forward with his right hand down is unusual, since his striking defense is normally so airtight.

McGregor vs. Frankie Edgar has to be the fight to make. You can’t just give Aldo a rematch after being knocked out in 13 seconds. I mean, I suppose you could, but I really think automatic rematches should be reserved for close fights. Of course, the UFC has been very quick to grant an automatic rematch for a title fight in recent years, regardless of whether the fight itself was competitive.

I expected Chris Weidman vs. Rockhold to be a pretty even match standing, but in practice, Rockhold was a lot faster and was able to land his strikes very consistently. It seemed like he was just a step ahead of Weidman, although Weidman had some success with kicks of his own. Weidman was definitely getting the better of Rockhold in the takedown game early, but Rockhold’s constant threats to choke Weidman seemed to really make Weidman hesitate in the clinch.

Weidman lost the second round pretty badly, but seemed to be doing well in the third round… when he threw a wheel kick in an apparent attempt to duplicate Vitor Belfort’s knockout victory. That was pretty dumb, but the fact that Rockhold was able to turn that into a takedown and full mount was a display of his skill and an indicator that Weidman was really hurting. Herb Dean should have stopped that fight in round three as Rockhold landed a huge number of uninterrupted strikes towards the end of the round. Weidman may have been moving and at least trying to fight back, but when a fighter is powerless to stop the onslaught of strikes being thrown at him, that should be considered “checkmate.”

I thought Jacare beat Romero 29-28, but if Jacare had won, I would have complained (once again) about the ten-point must scoring system. I know, the system isn’t going away, but Romero really hurt Jacare in that first round, while Jacare’s performances in rounds two and three were much less convincing. Even so, I think Jacare was the rightful winner by the letter of the law. Romero is a physical specimen but it’s really hard to see him doing well against Rockhold.

And then I have to mention Kevin Lee, a favorite of mine who Leonardo Santos made look bad on the prelims today. I was prepared to talk about how the UFC needed to take off the kid gloves and let Lee fight a top 15 opponent. But Santos exposed Lee’s lack of head movement and inability to adapt. It’s easy to forget that Lee has only been training martial arts for a few years – he doesn’t have the long history of training in any one discipline that most fighters have when they go into MMA. I think Lee should consider studying T.J. Dillashaw to figure out how to attack an opponent with more effective movement. He’s still a very good prospect but it’s never good to lose a fight by TKO.


5 responses to “Random Thoughts on UFC 194

  1. Mirko December 13, 2015 at 5:08 am

    I was really surprised when Aldo lost like that. Now I hope that Edgar gets the title shot and I expect McGregor to be huge favorite after this KO win over Aldo.
    Before I would favor Edgar in that fight, but now I just can’t see McGregor losing with that kind of KO power to anyone in the division.

  2. r.mattioli December 17, 2015 at 4:45 pm

    david,i agree that the 10 pt must is very flawed….some sort of hybrid system would be much more fair….some criteria that would indicate a dominant round(and still fall short of a 2 point round)…

    I also don`t like having a full point deduction in a 3 round fight….sometimes it`s absolutely warranted(the fence grabbing is something that I`ve seen turn fights on their ear)…..but it has to be egregious…a point deduction in a 3 round fight is devastating…..fights decided by a refs` decision regarding whether or not to deduct a point is something that`s always bothered me(considering the time… blood,sweat and tears,money and prestige involved…the way it can change a career)…..but,there has to be a threat of sanctions…

    damn shame some really smart people involved in the sport can`t sit down and come up with some alternative ideas to streamline and improve on the old, standard rules(that have basically been adopted from boxing,a completely different sport in so many ways)…….

    • David Williams December 17, 2015 at 10:27 pm

      You’re absolutely right. A lot of the rules used in MMA are adopted from boxing, which was done to help make the legalization of MMA palatable to legislators and commissions. Now the ten-point must system is entrenched and there’s no real demand for the system to be improved on.

      • JF1 December 18, 2015 at 2:13 pm

        1/2 point penalties needed since mma has fewer rounds than boxing
        When New York allows MMA, then rules will be up for review, says UFC, otherwise a major US state would have no say in rules. Looks like IV ban is being respected (!) so non-rehydrated heads. More TKO’s, perhaps, until fighters surrender muscle.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: